South Beds FoE Homepage

Translink


Luton Translink Busway – Proofs of Evidence (cont'd)

Letter to Persona Associates from South Beds FoE members Peter Hatswell and Roger Pepworth, 2005

 

Scheme Failings

The Translink Busway is not an efficient solution to our transport problems.

 

It fails for the following reasons:

  • It relies heavily on the existing road system with new bus lanes and bus priority measures aggravating the congestion. Our major roads frequently face gridlock due to incidents both locally and several miles away. This will make a reliable timetable hard to achieve and lead to poor customer support.

  • It’s high-speed section bypasses the areas in greatest need of public transport typically the A505 corridor. We are told that visitors to the Luton & Dunstable Hospital from Luton town centre will have a 7bph dedicated service on Translink  and a 7bph non-Translink service. How is this comparable with existing services of 20bph? In simple terms, this represents a reduction of about 30%. It would be more convenient for bus users if the existing bus services were enhanced with a park-and-ride facility to avoid the current parking deficit at the hospital.

  • The current plans show limited penetration into South Bedfordshire where the future needs could be significant. It is difficult to understand why airport passengers would chose to pay to use Translink from Luton Parkway when this is currently a free service.

  • There is no capacity for freight and only minor attempts to restrict greenhouse gas emissions.

  • The construction works will take 3 – 4 years and involve the movement of many thousands of tonnes of building materials. Drinking water extraction points are likely to be contaminated by run off from the massive concrete structures required for a busway.

  • There is no proven comparable system operating in the UK and this will be used as an excuse for late completion and a failure to meet capacity targets. Safety concerns particularly with snow or ice in the concrete guideway lifting or blocking the guide wheels could leave the drivers with sudden major steering problem. Rail designs are however fully proven.

  • More drivers are required for a bus service and recruitment difficulties are already a problem for local bus operators. This will make the Busway more expensive to operate than a train system.

  • The main beneficiaries of this scheme would appear to be the shops in Luton Town centre. This could further diminish trade for the struggling town centres of Dunstable & Houghton Regis.

 

National

Friends of the Earth

 

  home

back

next